Staffbase and PoliteMail at a glance
Both Staffbase and PoliteMail help organizations improve internal communications, but with different approaches.
Staffbase is an expansive employee communications platform which combines an intranet, employee app, and email. PoliteMail is purpose-built for internal email communications and helps communicators create, distribute, and measure email campaigns directly within Microsoft 365.
Staffbase has announced that their Email Classic software will move into maintenance mode in 2026 as customers transition to Staffbase Email within the entire Staffbase Studio. As organizations evaluate this transition and its cost implications, many communications teams are taking the opportunity to reassess their internal communications strategy and determine whether they need to take on such an expansive employee communications platform project or to select a more focused email first solution.
Staffbase vs. PoliteMail feature comparison
| Feature | Staffbase | PoliteMail |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Expansive employee communications platform | Purpose-built internal email communications platform |
| Microsoft 365 integration | Discontinued interface, limited backend integration | Built to run right inside Microsoft 365 Outlook |
| Internal email creation | Create and send employee emails as one feature of the Studio platform | Create and send impressive internal emails right from Outlook |
| Internal email analytics | Email analytics and engagement reporting | Detailed readership, attention, engagement, and comparative analytics based on actual email read time |
| Email Delivery | Either External SMTP or limited to 1 from address using M365 | Internal M365 email, no external flags and images download automatically without a click event |
| Employee newsletter management | Supported | Includes templates for employee newsletters and other recurring internal communications |
| Intranet capabilities | Intranet platform provided | Post content to Sharepoint |
| Employee app | Available | Not required |
| Multi-channel capabilities | Yes, within Staffbase Platform | Yes, within Microsoft 365 |
| Best fit | Organizations seeking an all-in-one employee communications platform | Organizations looking to improve internal email communications within Microsoft 365 |
Staffbase vs. PoliteMail for internal email
One of the biggest differences between Staffbase and PoliteMail is platform scope and how organizations purchase email capabilities.
PoliteMail is purpose-built for internal email communications and is available as a standalone solution within Microsoft 365. Organizations can create, distribute, and measure employee communications without investing in a broader employee communications platform. Because PoliteMail operates directly within Outlook and Microsoft 365, communicators can create and manage internal email campaigns within their existing communications environment rather than introducing a separate platform.
Beyond email creation and distribution, PoliteMail is designed to help communicators understand and improve communication effectiveness. Detailed readership analytics go beyond opens and clicks to measure engagement, attention, reading time, and comparative performance across campaigns. PoliteMail also includes seven years of benchmark data across ten S&P industry sectors, helping communicators understand how their employee communications perform compared to industry peers.
Another key difference is the employee experience. Communications sent through PoliteMail are delivered as familiar Outlook emails, making it easy for employees to read, forward, save, search, and engage with. Messages are received without any external warnings, opt-out options, or blocked images. Organizations can reach employees where they are already working instead of requiring them to visit another platform to access important information.
Staffbase takes a broad-reaching, expansive approach to employee communications. It is designed to provide multiple employee communication channels within their single platform experience, which includes an intranet, email, and a mobile app. The platform is intended to help organizations manage, publish, and distribute communications across these channels from a centralized administrative environment.
Migrating from Staffbase Email Classic? This is a good time to reassess.
If you’re currently using Staffbase Email Classic, the transition to Staffbase (Studio) Email requires not only the full expansive platform, but a migration of domains, senders, lists, content and branding, essentially a do-over, and thus presents an opportunity to reassess your internal communications tools strategy.
For some organizations, that transition will make sense. For others, it raises a different question:
Do you need a broader employee communications platform, or do you simply need a better internal email solution?
Organizations that have standardized on Microsoft 365, SharePoint, Microsoft Teams, or Viva Engage may find that a purpose-built internal email solution aligns more closely with their existing technology investments and communication workflows. Many organizations already have established intranet, collaboration, and employee communication channels in place, making Microsoft 365 the foundation of their digital workplace.
Rather than introducing an additional communication destination, communicators can create, distribute, and measure employee communications directly within the Microsoft tools employees already use every day. This approach allows organizations to enhance internal communications while building on existing Microsoft 365 investments and familiar employee experiences.
For teams focused primarily on employee newsletters, executive communications, HR communications, change management, and communication analytics, a platform transition can be an ideal time to evaluate whether a dedicated internal email solution provides the functionality they need while reducing platform complexity.
Get industry benchmarks from billions of
internal emails sent worldwide!
Discover email trends and analysis with PoliteMail's
Internal Email Benchmark Report.
Why organizations switch from Staffbase Email
Technology transitions often create the best opportunity to reassess whether a communications platform still fits the way an organization works. Platform migrations, evolving communication strategies, and shifting technology priorities often create opportunities to reassess whether an existing solution still aligns with organizational goals.
Rather than simply replacing one email tool with another, organizations often take the opportunity to determine whether they need a comprehensive employee communications platform or a solution focused specifically on internal email communications.
Common reasons organizations explore alternatives include:
- A desire to improve employee engagement performance and readership insights
- The need for deeper internal email analytics and engagement measurement
- An existing investment in Microsoft 365, SharePoint, and Microsoft Teams
- A preference for working within familiar Microsoft tools rather than introducing additional communication destinations
- Efforts to reduce technology complexity and platform overlap
- A renewed focus on demonstrating the impact of internal communications through measurable results
For organizations that already rely on Microsoft 365 as the foundation of their digital workplace, adopting a dedicated internal email solution can provide the communications capabilities they need while maximizing the value of existing investments.
Looking for a Staffbase alternative?
Both Staffbase and PoliteMail support employee communications, but they are designed for different communication strategies.
Staffbase provides a broad employee communications platform that brings together email, intranet, mobile, and employee experience capabilities within a single ecosystem. For organizations looking to consolidate multiple communication channels into one platform, that approach may be the right fit.
PoliteMail takes an email-first approach and is purpose-built for Microsoft 365, the communications platform already used by many organizations. PoliteMail helps internal communications teams create, send, and measure employee communications directly within Outlook and the Microsoft 365 tools employees use every day. Organizations can improve internal campaign performance, gain deeper communication analytics, and extend the value of their existing Microsoft 365 investment without adopting a broader employee communications platform.
For organizations evaluating a Staffbase alternative or considering their options as Staffbase Email Classic transitions to Staffbase Email, the decision ultimately comes down to communication strategy: Do you need a comprehensive employee communications platform, or a purpose-built internal email solution that works within your existing Microsoft 365 environment?
If your goal is to deliver more effective employee communications, measure and improve internal email engagement, and gain actionable readership insights without adding unnecessary platform complexity, PoliteMail is a strong alternative for organizations invested in Microsoft 365.
Learn how our internal email software empowers communicators with data-driven insights on employee engagement.
Book your 30-minute personalized demo today!
